Some seek higher capacity; optimism on the rise
NORTH COAST — Wine industry lenders in the North Bay have seen another uptick in borrower demand in the latter half of 2013, driven in part by a need to process a harvest that appears to rival last year’s crop and a continuing trend of mergers and acquisitions throughout the industry, according to those lenders.
Drawing parallels with the end of 2012, those lenders noted that the North Bay wine industry has once again experienced a large inflow of quality grapes and an improved outlook for consumer demand. That cash flow has boosted confidence, spurring demand for financing and attracting the attention of investors both inside and outside of the wine industry.
“This will probably be a record year in loan growth for Silicon Valley Bank’s wine division,” said Rob McMillan, who founded the St. Helena-based division in 1992. “There’s quite a bit of money that has come into the businesses. Along with that comes a demand for debt.”
While the record 2012 harvest came at a time when wineries faced a shortage of North Bay grapes, the prospect of another high quality, high-volume harvest in 2013 has some seeking financing to increase capacity, said Bill Rodda, vice president at American AgCredit.
Growers were able to command a premium on overages amid 2012′s intense demand. But the lack of available tank space this year has left some offering greater discounts on excess supply while looking harder for buyers, he said.
“Last year was a banner year. The wineries were in need of grapes at that time,” Mr. Rodda said. “Space was an issue in the industry this year.”
While the trend stands to somewhat mitigate the price of grapes in 2013, North Coast fruit still commands a significant premium that some wineries remain reluctant to pass on to the consumer. Those slimmer margins have forced many in the industry to be more analytical in their approach, and helped add more momentum to the current wave of mergers and acquisitions, Mr. McMillan said.
An effort by wineries to reduce expenses by acquiring vineyards and securing their own supply remains a trend, though Mr. McMillan noted that hedge funds and other buyers have been attracted by the industry as an investment as well.
“The kinds of acquisitions are really across the board,” he said.
The wine industry in general has benefitted from increased consumer spending since the recession, particularly in direct-to-consumer channels that have been an area of increased focus for many North Bay wineries, said Steve Herron, senior vice president and manager of the commercial lending group at Exchange Bank. That uptick in spending has helped boost confidence in the industry and a willingness to seek financing for growth, he said.
“We haven’t been as busy as we are now in the wine industry, in a broad sense, in at least 3 years,” he said.
Yet Mr. Herron and others expressed caution, noting that the discretionary nature of wine leaves the industry susceptible to economic downturns and changing demographics.
“The growth rate of wine is going down — it’s not negative, but it’s not like it was at the end of the ’90s,” said Mr. McMillan, who noted that appealing to the so-called “Millennial” generation remains a challenge. “It’s a sign of the maturation of the industry — having to focus and sharpen their pencils a bit more.”
Still, the North Bay’s status as a tourism destination — and the effort by the wine industry to attract those visitors — has helped to support that growth for companies based in the region and spurred some lenders to increase their focus on the industry.
For Bank of Marin, that focus has meant six new wine industry clients in the last six months, adding to a growing effort to serve the wine industry after the 2011 acquisition of Napa’s Charter Oak Bank.
“It’s slow and steady growth,” said Cheryl Cinelli, senior vice president and commercial banking officer for Bank of Marin. “The wine industry is certainly capital intensive. Banks really need to understand how things are going.”
Copyright © 1988–2015 North Bay Business Journal
View the policy for linking to website content.