North Bay economy looks positive in 2014

The regional economy is showing signs of continued growth in 2014. All six North Bay counties -- Lake, Marin, Mendocino, Napa, Solano and Sonoma -- are trending up in both leading and coincident indicators, showing that the region is in full recovery five years after the Great Recession of 2008--2009.

The U.S. economy continues to move at a relative moderate pace at the beginning of 2014.

Current forecasts have the U.S. economy growing gross domestic product (GDP) in real terms (inflation-adjusted) at 2.5 percent to 2.75 percent in 2014. Housing prices are also forecasted to continue their rise, though they are expected to slow down a bit from 2013's brisk pace. 

In California, median housing prices for single-family homes saw an increase of over 20 percent year over year in 2013, the largest increase since the mid-2000s.

For 2014, that increase is likely to be more like 8 percent to 10 percent -- maybe a bit less. 

Equity markets have reached new, nominal highs again; the S&P 500 is now close to its historic high in inflation-adjusted (real) terms.

Geopolitical issues, natural disasters and other potential downside risks have done little to shake investor confidence. Retail sales in the U.S. continue to climb steadily, as do American imports from other countries.Year of continued growth

All these signs point toward 2014 being a continued year of growth. In California, real economic growth is forecast to be over 3.4 percent in 2014, but growth is predicted at that pace or slightly higher through 2017 by the California Department of Finance for the Governor's budget.

Macroeconomists are usually concerned with three major markets: financial, labor, and goods/services markets. Financial markets are connected to labor and goods/services markets in that they are used to finance goods and services purchases.

Housing markets are where this connection is very obvious. Interest rate watching has now become a favorite pastime. 

Most economists are predicting a slow and steady increase in interest rates over 2014, where the 10-year U.S. Treasury note may rise to, or close to, 4 percent. 

One element of interest-rate growth is inflation expectations. The U.S. economy has yet to see much sign of rising prices that coincide with either growth or the slowing of an economic cycle.

In general, wage inflation drives general price levels higher. As wages rise, due to a labor market that has fewer workers, general prices rise as business transmit those higher wage demands to their customers through higher prices.

One side feeds the other, as more jobs are created and more wage and salary income is paid, consumers have more income to spend and can afford rising prices in the short-term.

Prices are forecast to rise slowly in 2014, keeping pace with the last three years at approximately 2 percent growth. In California, the cost of living is likely to rise a bit more quickly by 2.5 percent in 2014. 

The change in leadership to Chairwoman Janet Yellen is likely to change the Federal Reserve's basic philosophy.

As unemployment continues to fall at the national level, pressure on wages to rise will generate higher inflation expectations.

Once national unemployment falls below 6.5 percent, this is one of the triggers (along with GDP and payroll employment growth) for the Federal Reserve to begin explicit increases of short-term interest rates to combat expected inflation.North Bay economy grows

Given these contexts, the outlook is good for the North Bay. Sonoma, Napa and Marin counties all have seen job growth in 2013, and continue to emerge from the 2008--2009 recession in earnest.

North Bay counties all showed signs of recovery in housing markets. However, Lake County lost some workers, versus the other counties that all gained. 

Sonoma County's economy grew at 3.4 percent real growth, and generated 3,600 jobs. Housing markets provided a boost to Sonoma County homeowners and their wealth. At 21.2 percent growth from November 2012 to November 2013, this was the best year in housing markets since 2006.

Lake County saw very little price growth, though 2014 should be a better year for housing. Lake County also saw a loss of 140 jobs, about 1.1 percent of the jobs.

However, Lake County generated more income in 2013, about 4.2 percent real growth in productivity.

Mendocino County added 430 jobs, about 1.5 percent growth, while the county's economy grew about 2.8 percent. For these counties, job growth was seen in a broad mix of industries, where construction, manufacturing and services all grew in unison. 

Jobs related to tourism and hospitality (hotel, restaurants, recreation in general) increased in all counties.

For Napa County, there was a 1.2 percent increase in jobs, about 1,100 overall. Incomes grew by about 2.6 percent in Napa, driven almost completely by tourism, wine and related industries. The slower growth in Napa is likely a function of tourism beginning to peak a bit in the current business cycle. 

In Marin County, growth occurred in many services industries, where construction and manufacturing was somewhat flat. Marin County grew incomes by approximately 2.8 percent.

Housing markets in Napa and Marin counties are experiencing the highest median home price gains in the North Bay. But while Marin County prices grew by 21 percent, Napa's grew by 40 percent.

Madera County was the only county tracked by the California Association of Realtors (www.car.org) with faster price growth than Napa County for single-family homes. Napa's prices grew faster than those in any other Bay Area County. 

Solano County saw jobs grow by 4,400 new workers in 2013, also across a broad base of industries. This represents 3.5 percent job growth, the fastest growth among the six counties. Solano County's gross county product is estimated to have grown by 3.2 percent. Median home prices in Solano grew just over 24 percent in 2013 also.

In short, 2013 was a year of continued growth in all labor markets beyond Lake County, and 2014 (given the larger contexts) also looks to be a year of growth.Indicators point to more growth

Sonoma State University generates economic indicators for these six counties based on a methodology that is similar to the Conference Board's method for the United States overall and first done by an alumnus of SSU's Economics Department, Toby Tyler.

Leading and coincident indicators also show that 2014 will be a year of continued growth. A leading indicator is a mix of six factors that are assumed to lead or happen before changes result in employment and income. The six factors are as follows:Notices of default: A signal of housing market inventory changes for broader economic reasons;Residential building permits: A sign of housing demand expanding;The U.S. Leading Economic Indicator, as published by the Conference Board (www.conference-board.org);A help-wanted index as published by the California Employment Development Department for local areas;Agricultural prices of milk, lumber and wine grapes as an indicator of demand for those products; andNew initial claims for unemployment insurance as a way to track adjustments coming to labor markets.

These data generate a weighted average index that represents the forecast for these county economies.

The North Bay economic indicators are rising in all counties. Lake County's indicators, while moving more slowly upward, are still rising.

Figure 1 shows the leading indicator for Sonoma, Marin and Napa counties, and Figure 2 for Lake, Mendocino and Solano counties.

The coincident indicator is made up of three components, each representing employment and income directly:The first is non-farm employment, or how employers are hiring locally outside of agriculture. This includes government workers. The second indicator is retail sales, reflecting more purchases within the local area. The third is an estimate of personal income using the Bureau of Economic Analysis (www.bea.gov) data for each county as a base and then estimating the most recent year.

The coincident indicator is a weighted average of these three variables. Figures 3 and 4 mirror Figure 1 and 2 in terms of the counties shown for the coincident indicator.Drought could be economic shock

The leading and coincident indicators all suggest that the North Bay will continue to grow in 2014. The national and state economies are also forecast to grow. 

If there is any anomaly in the forecasts for our region and the state of California, it would be the water conditions and how severe a drought may takes place. That will begin to change agricultural prices upward for reasons of normal demand and reduced supply, which drives higher prices for supply-shock reasons.

If the rains come in the spring and drought that reduces agricultural supply is avoided, 2014 will be another year of strong recovery in the North Bay....

Robert Eyler, Ph.D., is professor of economics and director of the Center for Regional Economic Analysis at Sonoma State University.

Show Comment