To many observers, opposition to George Lucas's proposed Grady Ranch digital film studio must seem like a scene from a bad movie.
The first thing to understand is that the master plan under which the project is proposed was approved by county officials in 1996. Sixteen years later, the famed filmmaker is asking to build his dream studio in the very place he started and in the county that has benefited so much artistically and economically from his genius.[poll id="11"]
This NBBJ Pulse Poll runs through April 3. View all polls.
The Marin County Planning Commission, after a year of examination and extensive public input, unanimously approved the 270,000-square-foot building on Feb. 27. Many have noted that the building is actually smaller than what was approved 16 years ago. "Overall, there is less impact and additional benefits," a county environmental official said. One county supervisor was quoted as saying "It's less intense. It's less everything."
The studio and other facilities -- designed in Mission-style architecture -- will be hidden from view behind a berm. Creeks will be restored and trails created. Lucas officials say that with Grady and other projects, more than 3,200 acres, some of it potentially developable, will be protected as open space.
But apparently even this was not enough. In a matter of days after the planning commission approval, a Lucas Valley homeowner group filed a challenge citing "all points raised in public comment letters" as the basis of its appeal.
How many times has the North Bay seen this movie?
On April 3, the Marin County Board of Supervisors is scheduled to hear the appeal. Arguments will be made. At some point decisions will be taken. Lawsuits will be threatened and perhaps filed.
Through it all, Marin's leaders will be tested, but in the end they must ask themselves: "What community would not give everything to have a project of such quality and promise?"
A study of the economic benefits of the project is impressive. Construction and operation of the studio would create 690 jobs, including 460 during two-and-a-half years to complete the project, according to Robert Eyler, an economics professor at Sonoma State University who was commissioned by Skywalker Properties to analyze the project.